Showing posts with label loyalty. Show all posts
Showing posts with label loyalty. Show all posts

Tuesday, October 23, 2007

Full Circle or: "A priori" and "a posteriori"


"What came before...what comes after"


Good Morning: Okay, here's my "Full Circle Inference" I mentioned I'd blog about last Friday:

Does anybody find the connection between "GreenPoints" and the Pay By Touch Logo a little bit interesting? They're both green points. I find that to be quite the coincidence. But as with all coincidences, I always question, "Why"? What is the meaning behind the coincidences? At the end of the day, when the smoke clears, the answer seemingly always "points" to what I refer to as the "Full Circle" inference. Another name for it is "a priori" "a posteriori" if you want me to go latin on you.

The terms "a priori" and "a posteriori" are used in philosophy to distinguish between deductive and inductive reasoning, respectively. As coincidence would have it, loyalty marketing appeals to both the deductive and inductive reasoning powers of consumers. That fact is the driving force behind the popularity of loyalty programs and why 45% of Visa's Interchange Rate is comprised of covering the cost of rewards programs.

As I mentioned, the phrases "a priori" and "a posteriori" are Latin in origin, and literally mean "from what comes before" and "from what comes later", respectively.

It has been also called "logical positism." which grew from the discussions of Moritz Schlick's Vienna Circle and Hans Reichenbach's Berlin Circle in the 1920s and 1930s. Which is why I call it the Full Circle inference.


S&H GreenStamps started the loyalty industry 110 years ago, and today, using software programming, which coincidentally (not) is made up of 1's and 0's, they have created potentially the best loyalty program in the industry.

After acquiring S&H for 100 million, Pay By Touch can create the 1-to-1 marketing "end all" 111 years later. Now I'm no numerologist (don't even really know what one does) but my instincts tell me that this is going to be big.

Let's look at the generics of what "loyalty marketing" is:

Loyalty marketing: From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia

Branding, Product Marketing and Loyalty marketing all form part of the customer proposition – the subjective assessment by the customer of whether to purchase a brand or not based on the integrated combination of the value they receive from each of these marketing disciplines.

Loyalty marketing is an approach to marketing, based on strategic management, in which a company focuses on growing and retaining existing customers through incentives. The discipline of customer loyalty marketing has been around for many years, but expansions from it merely being a model for conducting business to becoming a vehicle for marketing and advertising have made it omnipresent in consumer marketing organizations since the mid- to late-1990s.

Some of the newer loyalty marketing industry insiders, such as Chris X. Moloney and Fred Reichheld, have claimed a strong link between customer loyalty marketing and customer referral. In recent years, a new marketing discipline called "customer advocacy marketing" has been combined with or replaced "customer loyalty marketing." To the general public, many airline miles programs, hotel frequent guest programs and credit card incentive programs are the most visible customer loyalty marketing programs.

History of loyalty marketing

On May 1, 1981 American Airlines launched the first full-scale loyalty marketing program of the modern era with the AAdvantage miles program. This revolutionary program was the first to reward "frequent fliers" with reward miles that could be accumulated and later redeemed for free travel. Many airlines and travel providers saw the incredible value in providing customers with an incentive to use a company exclusively and be rewarded for their loyalty. Within a few years, dozens of travel industry companies launched similar programs. The AAdvantage program now boasts over 50 million active members.

American Airlines' AAdvantage program can trace its roots to S&H Greenstamps which were a popular retail reward coupon issued very commonly from the 1930s through the 1980s. Typically, as a consumer shopped at various grocery and dry good stores, they would receive a set number of Green Stamps that could be pasted into booklets and redeemed for prizes.

"A Priori"

What came before was, "GreenStamps,"
the world's first rewards program, operated by the Sperry and Hutchinson company (S&H), founded in 1896 by Thomas Sperry and Shelly Hutchinson. Here's an interesting backgrounder I was unaware of:

During the 1960s, the rewards catalog printed by the company was the largest publication (I thought it was Sears) in the United States and the company issued three times as many stamps as the U.S. Postal Service.

Once again, coincidentally, customers would receive stamps at the checkout counter of Pay By Touch's biggest niche markets, namely: supermarkets and gas stations.

"A Posteriori"

What came after, or "a posteriori" was "GreenPoints" which is now Pay By Touch. When greenpoints are combined with Pay By Touch's proprietary SmartShop program, it is poised to become the most rewarding loyalty experience, available, period. After all, who cares if you get "rewarded" with $1.00 off Corn King Bacon if your an Oscar Meyer bacon kinda guy? Because SmartShop gives discounts on Oscar Meyer Bacon to the Oscar Meyer Bacon eating family, the numbers are amazing. Instead of a .0065 coupon redemption rate, the SmartShop redemption rate is above 40%! There's no denying the statistical significance of those numbers.

A lot of people questioned the acquisition of S&H, including, initially, myself. But after further thought, and absolutely no insights, as per usual, from Pay By Touch, I now firmly believe that the acquisition of S&H Solutions will empower Pay By Touch to create the best loyalty marketing program in the history of the industry.

That is the main impetus behind this post...to alter the perception of the S&H acquisition. I'll attempt to do that by providing some insights as to how it is destined to become a powerful play. By the way, It might not have been a bad idea for Pay By Touch themselves to have done that for, if not the analysts, at least the shareholders of the company. It's one thing to keep the competition guessing, but an entirely different thing to keep your shareholders guessing. But then again, that's something that is easily fixed, so I'll move forward...

According to Ron Pedersen, CEO for S&H Solutions, "Together we aim to transform the personalized marketing industry by offering unprecedented opportunities for relevance marketing and customization."

The acquisitions of 7th Street Software, Capture Resource and S&H combined create a whole new entity, one that has a future primed to be a star. They got it right. This, from their website:
Pay By Touch Personalized Marketing offers retailers and manufacturers proprietary, next generation services that work to maximize the shopper lifetime value, increasing customer satisfaction and providing a true competitive advantage. The future of individualized retail marketing, our cost-effective solutions increase shopper frequency, basket size and retention.

Once again, ironically, coincidentally, whateverdentally, S&H's two largest markets were supermarkets and gas stations. SmartShop has the grocery market figured out. Pay By Touch is beginning installs at Shell Gas Stations in Chicago. A cross promotion between Jewel/Osco, Cub Foods and Shell Gas Stations is blatantly recommended once the installs at Shell are complete. But what of other gas stations?

I believe they are an ideal target market for a new and improved Greenpoints Rewards program. But don't reward Visa purchases,
as Visa is not only our competition in payments, but also in rewards. Obviously those are our two core businesses.

Make no mistake, Visa is the enemy. Once again, coincidentally, (and fortunately) Visa is also the enemy of Gas Station operators, since Visa sucks up 66% of their profits so they can "reward" the more affluent. The full circle is that Pay By Touch can come from help, and this new "Petrol Rewards" program will be one which can be tied to check and debit transactions. The timing is perfect. What came before: Visa (a priori) and what comes after: Pay By Touch (a posteriori)

The perception that Interchange is exorbitantly high, combined with the fact that 45% of interchange revenues go to rewards programs, is resulting in the desire of gas station owners to shift their payments to checks, debit or cash.
This shift in perception, will provide momentum towards shifting the payments they accept. In essence, the new PBT program would also be "rewarding" to the Gas Station owners as well, as it will give them back their profits.

So it seems like a perfect time to create a synergistic platform customized towards that sector. I have a pretty good idea on how to go about that.

Coincidentally, I have an "employment clause" in my contract with Pay By Touch and I think it might be that time to exercise it.

Talk about full circles...

Friday, October 19, 2007

A Closer Look at Pay By Touch Empowered, Club DLM

Dorothy Lane Market (DLM) signed a deal to implement personalized marketing kiosks and biometric payment services from Pay By Touch's throughout the entire chain by the end of July 2007, including an upgrade to the store's Club DLM customer loyalty program.

By adopting the Pay By Touch platform, the Club DLM loyalty program will "evolve into its new form", being re-branded as Club DLM 2.U. Under the new program, upgraded members will receive personalized offers from a kiosk as they enter the store (using a biometric finger scan or swiping their Club DLM card to identify themselves).

When shoppers enter the store, they scan their finger or swipe their DLM Club Card at the kiosk. The kiosk prints out a customized page containing up to 10 offers for products that the shopper buys most, based on past shopping history records. At the check-out, shoppers don't need to present the offer sheet because the offers that they've been assigned that day are automatically redeemed and deducted from their bill.

Grocers that have adopted Pay By Touch's kiosk-based personalised marketing system also include Green Hills Market in New York, Foodtown in New York and New Jersey, and Shop n' Save in Pennsylvania.

At the end of August, I blogged about an article in Progressive Grocer which stated that Dorothy Lane Market's biometric loyalty and payment service had already been used in transactions totaling 24 percent of sales, even though the program was launched "only two weeks ago".

As always, click the pictures to enlarge and enable you to read the print.

It said that the system, powered by San Francisco-based Pay By Touch's SmartShop, went live for shoppers on July 25, and had driven a 26 percent average redemption rate, as opposed to a 0.6 percent average redemption rate on FSI coupons. (Sunday Inserts)


Not unlike Green Hills Grocer, Dorothy Lane is no stranger to loyalty programs, and its Club DLM is well known in the industry. So, in essence, the two foremost and well renowned loyalty and rewards pioneers in the industry have both chosen to empower their industry famous programs with Pay By Touch enhancements.

The SmartShop is an enhancement to the program. "Previously, club members would get some mass offers and some personalized offers," Amy Brinkmoeller, Dorothy Lane's manager of information systems told Progressive Grocer.

According to the retailer, more than 36 percent of active shoppers - those who shop the stores on a weekly basis - used SmartShop.

One number Brinkmoeller, who spearheaded the SmartShop deployment, said she is particularly happy about is the number of users now paying via ACH through the Pay By Touch system.

Pay By Touch has invested a lot of time and money shaping this program and, ironically, should themselves be rewarded with a excellent return on their investments. It all started back in December 2005, with the acquisition of 7th Street Software, and Covena, two companies that had made tremendous headway on technology of One-to-One Marketing introducing an entirely new approach referred to as "Statistical Inference." (also known as "Bayesian Inference")

Speaking of "inferences" I've got one: I'll call it the "Full Circle" Inference.

See my next post for details....

45% of Interchange pays for Reward Programs

Yesterday, I blogged about Dubai cutting off Visa because of Interchange Fees and how that could create some momentum for Pay By Touch and other alternative payment companies. Today, I thought I'd do a backgrounder on Interchange:

First, I'd like to make note of an interesting fact. Click on the chart on the left and you'll find out that "Rewards" constitute an amazing 45% of Interchange Costs. That means that loyalty and rewards programs are responsible for almost half of the fees charged by Visa. No wonder Pay By Touch has put such a high priority on their personalized marketing program, which produces "instant" rewards at a fraction of the cost. Here are additional facts on Interchange:

From UnfairCreditCardFees.com




CREDIT CARD INTERCHANGE FEES
Background Each year, in addition to interest, late fees, over-the-limit charges and other fees charged by credit card companies and their banks, consumers pay billions of dollars in hidden fees that never appear on their monthly statements.

These hidden charges are called credit card “interchange fees.” Credit card companies and their banks charge them to merchants every time a credit or debit card is used to pay for a purchase. As much as $2 of every $100 you spend goes to card issuers.

Interchange fees are fixed in secret. There is no real competition in the credit card business. Visa and MasterCard control 80 percent of the credit card purchase volume.

Visa and MasterCard each separately work with their member banks collectively to set the price of interchange fees. This is illegal price fixing and it hurts consumers and merchants. Because banks benefit from higher interchange fees, Visa and MasterCard compete to charge the highest rate.


Interchange fees are hidden from consumers


Consumers have a right to know how much they are really paying when they use a credit card, just as they do when they use an ATM machine. But the credit card interchange fee is the biggest fee you've never heard of. Unlike other credit card fees that show up on your monthly statement, the credit card interchange fee is hidden, and credit card company rules make it practically impossible for merchants to tell
customers how much they are really paying.
Interchange fees are too high


Credit card companies and their banks collected more than $36 billion in interchange fees last year alone, up 17 percent from 2005 and 117 percent since 2001. The average American family is now paying more than $300 a year in hidden credit card interchange fees. Merchants are effectively left to pass along the credit card interchange fee to consumers in the form of higher prices. The credit card interchange fee increases the price of everything consumers buy, even those who don't use plastic and choose instead to pay for their purchases in cash or by check.

With the price of gas at more than $3 a gallon, credit card companies and their banks are collecting as much as 8 cents a gallon in interchange fees, even as they continue trying to keep consumers in the dark about how much they are really paying.

Americans are paying pay the highest interchange fees in the world, an average of two percent, compared with less than one percent in most other industrialized countries.


Card companies and their banks collect more revenue from interchange fees by increasing the interchange rate and by pushing consumers into higher-rate premium and rewards cards that carry a higher interchange rate.


The card companies and their banks also increase their revenue from the interchange fee when more customers use credit and debit cards to pay for purchases and when total sales volume increases.
The system is structured so that credit card companies and their banks make more money on each transaction as prices increase.

For example, even though it costs essentially the same to process a $1 transaction and a $100 transaction, the card companies and the banks collect a much higher interchange fee on the $100 transaction because the fee is based on a percentage of the total sale.


Interchange fees only benefit card companies and banks

The credit card interchange fee was originally intended, among other things, to pay for transaction processing, but even as new technology continues to lower the cost of credit card processing, credit card interchange fees keep going up.


In fact, according to a recent study, Visa and MasterCard spend only 13 percent of the credit card interchange fees they collect on card transaction processing.

Most of the rest goes to profits, rewards programs that benefit primarily more affluent cardholders and for all those unsolicited credit card offers that fill our mailboxes every day, a total of nine billion pieces of junk mail every year.
Many of those unsolicited mailings include so-called "convenience checks" that can be stolen and cashed by someone other than the authorized card holder.

Yet the card companies and their banks spend only four percent of the interchange fees they collect on measures to protect consumers from this and other forms of credit card fraud.


Action is required


Americans have a fundamental right to know about the credit card fees they are forced to pay. Visa and MasterCard have kept interchange fees hidden for years, but the issue has now emerged as a major public policy concern.
Congress is looking at interchange fees and other unfair credit card practices, and nearly 50 lawsuits have been filed in federal court charging that current interchange practices violate federal antitrust law. We need full investigations of the broken interchange fee system and reforms to make the system more competitive and transparent so that it better serves consumers and merchants alike.

Wednesday, May 9, 2007

Pay By Touch Strengthens SmartShop Program

To facilitate rapid consumer adoption and give merchants maximum flexibility, Pay By Touch has added a card-based option to its biometric SmartShop(TM) service.

SmartShop, powered by Pay By Touch, gives shoppers customized offers on the products they buy most when they enter the store -- before they shop.

Pay By Touch, the leader in biometric payment and personalized marketing, is offering card-based SmartShop in addition to the biometric SmartShop service, which launched at NRF in January, 2007.

SmartShop provides merchants and consumer packaged goods companies (CPGs) with an unprecedented return on investment (ROI) by enabling them to deliver the right offer to the right shopper at the right time - both in-store and online.

"At Pay By Touch, we understand that each retailer is unique. Card-based SmartShop enables merchants to immediately engage their best shoppers by letting them use their existing loyalty cards to get personalized offers," said John Rogers, Founder, Chairman and CEO, Pay By Touch. "SmartShop offers unparalleled, automated targeting based on preferences in each particular store. There is no better way for merchants and manufacturers to reach their targets."

Research shows that 70 percent of buying decisions are made in-store, and that less than one percent of grocery store coupons are ever redeemed(1). As a result, millions of marketing dollars are wasted every year. SmartShop turns every shopper into a uniquely qualified marketing lead and delivers value to consumers, merchants and manufacturers alike.

SmartShop enhances retailers' existing loyalty programs by delivering added value to their most important customers. It also provides a robust loyalty solution for retailers who do not yet have a program in place. Best of all, SmartShop 'learns' from each shopping trip to generate the next set of relevant rewards.

Card-based SmartShop at Shop 'n Save and Foodtown Stores.

Card-based SmartShop has been implemented by Shop 'n Save stores in the Pittsburgh, Pennsylvania area, as well as Foodtown stores in New York and New Jersey.

These merchants will migrate to biometric SmartShop, and adopt Pay By Touch's biometric payment solution, to let shoppers identify themselves, pay for purchases and redeem rewards with the simple touch of a finger.

"We are extremely pleased with the SmartShop service, which is branded 'Shop 'n Save Personalized Perks' in three of our Pittsburgh-area stores," said Greg Hartley, Owner of three Shop 'n Save locations. "The service is a huge hit with our shoppers, with kiosks in each store receiving more than 300 visits a day. We are excited to continue using the program and we are looking forward to seeing the kiosk in other Shop 'n Save stores."

Early results reveal the value of the SmartShop service. These merchants can experience:

* Twenty to 50 percent shopper adoption of SmartShop
* Eight to 12 percent sales lift among
customers using SmartShop
* A 25 to 30 percent reduction in
advertising and direct mail printing and distribution costs

SC Johnson Among Early CPG Adopters

Already, several leading CPGs have joined the program, including SC Johnson and more.

These companies are leveraging the SmartShop platform to deliver personalized, highly relevant coupons and deepen their relationships with consumers.

With SmartShop, CPGs can experience:

* Twenty percent+ sales lift
* Four to five times greater redemption rates than traditional FSIs
* Twenty to 50 percent reduction in marketing costs per unit sold at retail
* A significant reduction in handling costs

How SmartShop Works:

1. When shoppers enter the store, they simply scan their loyalty card at the SmartShop kiosk to get personalized offers based on their purchase history.

2. Shoppers receive an 8 1/2 x 11 print-out with 16 customized offers on the products they buy most, and then head into the aisles to shop.

3. Shoppers scan their loyalty card at check-out to redeem their offers. They do not need to bring the print-out to check-out; no paper coupons are required.

SmartShop gives merchants customer-based metrics and accurate data that improves the efficacy of marketing efforts. It is easy to implement, with a Web-based management system for algorithmic campaign creation and real-time targeting. The service provides robust analytics to make reporting and account settlement both easy and accurate.

Availability: The card-based version of SmartShop, powered by Pay By Touch, is available now. For sales inquiries, call Sarah Cole at (415) 371- 5620 or email her at : sarah.cole@paybytouch.com

You mad,(could have .Ed) See SmartShop at FMI: An interactive demo of the SmartShop service will be available at the Pay By Touch booth, #411 at The New FMI Show plus MARKETECHNICS(R), May 6-8, 2007 at McCormick Place in Chicago, IL

Wednesday, February 21, 2007

Supervalu Tests PBT Personalized Marketing

Supervalu's Shop 'n Save has implemented PBT's personal marketing platform SmartShop, which will utilize the unique application to to improve its incentive marketing program, a core strategy for grocery stores.

Three Pittsburgh-area locations of the grocery store chain are testing a new program which will be called "Shop 'n Save Personalized Perks" based on a software application established by a San Francisco-based firm called Pay By Touch.

While most loyalty card programs offer customers sales prices on a variety of different products each week, the new Shop 'n Save Perks Card provides cardholders with discounts on products they buy most. This results in huge savings in terms of hit and miss mass marketing.

The program seeks to build upon each shopper's preferences, offering them customized discounts based on their regular buying habits.

To use the program, shoppers scan their cards upon entering the store and receive a printout of products available for sale to them. When they buy those items, they use their cards for discounts.

"With Shop 'n Save Personalized Perks, shoppers can get extra savings on their favorite products right as they walk into the store," said Bill Lipsky, Director of Merchandising for Shop 'n Save, a subsidiary of Minneapolis-based wholesaler SUPERVALU Inc. "It's yet another way that we are delivering additional value to our shoppers."

There is no word as of yet as to how long Shop 'n Save will choose to test the program or if it will roll it out at its more than 20 other area stores.

A spokeswoman for Pay by Touch said the three Pittsburgh-area stores are the first SUPERVALU grocery locations to use the program by in the country.

In other news, Hebert's Supermarkets announced that Paycheck Secure(R), a biometric check cashing service, is available at all three Hebert's locations.

Paycheck Secure, powered by Pay By Touch, uses a simple finger scan to authenticate customers' identities to cash payroll or government checks. Paycheck Secure first was implemented in the Hebert's of Henderson store in March 2006, and now the retailer has expanded the service to Hebert's Supermarket and Hebert's Superette, both located in downtown Breaux Bridge, Louisiana.

"This is the best check cashing system we have had yet," said Ken Mouton, general manager of Hebert's Supermarkets. "It made sense to expand the service not only to provide more convenience for our customers, but also to help prevent check fraud across all of our stores."

Signing up to cash checks using Paycheck Secure is quick and easy. Customers simply provide a photo ID, two finger scans, and have a digital photo taken right in the store. Once enrolled, customers can quickly and securely cash payroll checks with a quick finger scan at any Hebert's store.

"Paycheck Secure offers a unique way for Hebert's customers to cash their checks rapidly and securely," said John Rogers, Founder, Chairman, and CEO of Pay By Touch. "The service also helps merchants like Hebert's dramatically reduce fraud by leveraging biometric technology to verify customers' identities."